Skip to content
AutaxoAutaxo

Cash Book Without a TSE at a Car Dealership: What Is Allowed and When Software Needs a TSE

28 min read Cash Book TSE Car Trade Cash Recordkeeping Section 146a AO

In brief

Under current law (as of November 2026), a cash book without a TSE remains possible, for example as an open cash drawer (offene Ladenkasse) kept by hand. By reverse inference from the questions and answers of the German Federal Ministry of Finance, the same applies to an electronic cash book that records only daily and closing figures. If, on the other hand, the software also records sales, services and their settlement, or if cash payments can be recorded in an invoicing program, then to that extent it has a cash register function in the view of the German tax authorities and needs a certified TSE for it under section 146a AO.

On this page (13 sections)

“Why don’t you simply offer the cash book without a TSE?” We have heard this fair question often since we started setting up new cash registers only as an add-on module with a technical security system (TSE). A TSE logs every transaction as soon as it begins and secures the data so that later changes and gaps become apparent.

The short answer: a cash book without a TSE remains possible, but not in every form. With an electronic cash book, it depends on what the software can do. In the Autaxo cash book, you record cash payments on the individual invoice and settle them there. In the view of the German tax authorities, that is a cash register function (Kassenfunktion), for which section 146a of the German Fiscal Code (Abgabenordnung, AO) requires a certified TSE, and that is why we only set up new cash registers with a TSE.

Editorial team: Autaxo GmbH. Research as of November 18, 2026. This article is based on official sources and, in two marked places, on specialist literature. Anything taken from the application decree on the German Fiscal Code (AEAO), an administrative instruction to the tax offices, or from the questions and answers of the German Federal Ministry of Finance (BMF) on the Cash Register Act (Kassengesetz), the BMF FAQ, is marked as the view of the tax authorities. Clarify your individual case with your tax advisor.

Is a Cash Book Without a TSE Allowed?

Yes, in several forms. In the view of the tax authorities, whether a TSE is needed depends on the scope of functions, not on whether something is called a cash book.

The TSE requirement under section 146a AO applies to electronic recording systems. Under section 1(1) of the Cash Register Anti-Tampering Ordinance (KassenSichV), these are electronic or computer-based cash register systems and electronic cash registers (Registrierkassen). This requirement is not new: section 146a AO has applied since January 1, 2020 (Article 97 section 30(1) of the Introductory Act to the German Fiscal Code, EGAO). The overview shows the situation as of November 2026.

Form of cash recordkeepingTSE needed?Basis
Open cash drawer (offene Ladenkasse): cash is recorded by hand without technical aidsNoTSE requirement only for electronic recording systems (section 146a(1) AO), no statutory obligation to use such a system (BT-Drs. 18/9535, p. 2, AEAO on section 146 no. 3.1, BMF FAQ, general question 3)
Electronic cash book that records only daily and closing figuresNo, by reverse inferenceInference from the BMF FAQ, scope, question 15
Electronic cash book that also records sales, services and their settlementYes, in the view of the tax authoritiesBMF FAQ, scope, question 15
Invoicing or inventory management program with a cash payment functionYes, in the view of the tax authorities, for the part of the software concernedBMF FAQ, scope, questions 2 to 4
Electronic accounting programNoSection 1(1) sentence 2 no. 3 KassenSichV
System that accepts neither cash nor vouchers nor electronic money on siteNo, in the view of the tax authoritiesBMF FAQ, scope, question 10, AEAO on section 146a no. 1.2

The row on the electronic cash book for daily and closing figures only is based on a reverse inference: the BMF FAQ expressly mentions only the case with a cash register function. Even without a TSE, cash transactions must be recorded daily and, as a rule, individually (section 146(1) AO). A cash book for daily and closing figures only does not replace these individual records.

When Does an Electronic Cash Book Have a Cash Register Function?

In the view of the tax authorities, when it records not only daily and closing figures but also sales, services and their settlement.

The term “cash register function” does not appear in the law but in the application decree: an electronic recording system has one if it can serve to record and process payment transactions made wholly or partly in cash. The same applies to comparable electronic forms of payment used on site, such as electronic money, for example a stored-value card (Geldkarte) or a virtual customer account, and to vouchers, prepaid cards or coupons accepted on site in lieu of money. A physical cash drawer is not required (AEAO on section 146a no. 1.2). Software can also be such a system: the official explanatory memorandum to the Cash Register Anti-Tampering Ordinance expressly includes software solutions and gives cash sales modules as an example (Bundestag printed paper (Bundestagsdrucksache, BT-Drs.) 18/12221, p. 10).

On the electronic cash book, the BMF FAQ says (in our translation, as with all quotations from German sources in this article; the source remains the German original): “The tax authorities base their assessment on the scope of functions.” According to the FAQ, an electronic cash book has a cash register function and falls under section 146a AO if it records not only daily and closing figures but also sales of goods and services rendered and their settlement (BMF FAQ, scope, question 15). Daily and closing figures include, for example, the cash balance, cash business income and business expenses, withdrawals and contributions.

For invoicing programs, the FAQ states in question 4: “If an invoicing system or an invoicing module makes it possible to record cash payment transactions, it has a cash register function within the meaning of no. 1.2 of the AEAO on section 146a.” According to the FAQ, in a larger software package only the part that can record and process cash payment transactions is affected, not the entire program (question 2).

To illustrate: one customer pays the remaining purchase price for their vehicle in cash, another pays a workshop invoice or accessories in cash. If you record such payments in the software on the respective invoice, this goes beyond recording daily figures. A specialist article for car dealerships assesses it as follows: what matters is whether cash business transactions can be processed with the software in use. The decisive factor is how the software works, not how it is actually used (Teutemacher, ASR 2021).

For context: this distinction is based on the view of the tax authorities. The application decree binds the tax offices, not the courts. By its own account, the guidance in the BMF FAQ has no legal force, and the tax office decides in the individual case (BMF FAQ, preliminary note to the guidance). In the specialist literature, there is also a dissenting voice on this broad interpretation (Teutemacher, tax & bytes 2025).

Are Manufacturers Allowed to Offer a Cash Register Module Without a TSE?

In the view of the tax authorities, only if a TSE can be connected. Section 146a(1) sentence 5 AO currently prohibits commercially advertising or commercially placing on the market electronic recording systems, and software for them, that do not meet the statutory requirements (as of November 2026). The law does not speak of offering, of cash books or of connecting a TSE, and it does not apply only to manufacturers. It is the view of the tax authorities that a cash book in which you record cash payments on the invoice is one of the systems that must meet these requirements. That is why we keep the two apart.

What the Law Says

The wording, in our translation:

“It is prohibited, within the territory to which this Code applies, to commercially advertise or commercially place on the market, for use within the meaning of sentences 1 to 3, electronic recording systems, software for electronic recording systems and certified technical security systems that do not meet the requirements described in sentences 1 to 3.”

Sentences 1 to 3 require the system to record every transaction individually, completely, correctly, promptly and in an orderly manner, and the system and records to be protected by a certified TSE. It is the TSE that is certified, not the cash register software. The certification body is the German Federal Office for Information Security (BSI).

How the Tax Authorities Interpret the Prohibition

With regard to the TSE, the tax authorities look at whether one can be connected: under this view, a cash register system to which no TSE can be connected may not be placed on the market. The system and the TSE, on the other hand, may be advertised and placed on the market independently of each other (AEAO on section 146a no. 1.18.2, BMF FAQ, prohibition topic, question 2).

For invoicing programs, the guidance concludes: an invoicing system or invoicing module in which cash payment transactions can be recorded may only be placed on the market if a TSE can be connected (BMF FAQ, scope, question 4). The prohibition contains no exception for individual customer requests.

Is It Enough Simply Not to Use the Cash Payment Function?

Not according to the guidance of the German Federal Ministry of Finance. It is sufficient that the cash payment function can be activated in the software.

The BMF FAQ puts it this way in question 11 on scope: “The actual use of this function is irrelevant.” If a business can use the cash register module, connecting a TSE is mandatory according to the guidance (question 3).

This also answers an obvious suggestion: offering the cash book optionally without a TSE. Under the law, the obligation to protect the system and records with a certified TSE lies with the business that uses the system (section 146a(1) AO). Our conclusion: a cash book that let you opt out of the TSE would not help you. That is why we only set up new cash registers in Autaxo with a TSE.

The situation is different if a system does not allow any cash payment transactions on site at all. According to the guidance, it then does not need a TSE (BMF FAQ, scope, question 10). The fact that the software cannot record cash payments must, according to the same guidance, be demonstrated in the system documentation (question 11). Under the application decree, however, electronic money used on site, for example a stored-value card or a virtual customer account, and vouchers or prepaid cards accepted on site in lieu of money are also covered by the cash register function (AEAO on section 146a no. 1.2). According to the guidance, systems that accept only cashless payments do not need a TSE if they are completely and traceably separated from the systems with a cash register function (recording system topic, question 4). This could change from 2028; more on this below.

Why Is the Cash Book in Autaxo Only Available with a TSE?

We only set up new cash registers with a TSE because in the Autaxo cash book you do not record cash as a daily total but post it to the individual transaction. You take cash payment for an invoice, and Autaxo posts the payment and creates the receipt for it. This is precisely the point on which the tax authorities base their view.

This section describes our product (as of November 2026):

  • Changeover: Since November 3, 2026, we only set up new cash registers as the “Cash register & TSE” add-on module.
  • TSE: New cash registers get a certified cloud TSE from fiskaly. We set it up for you after you order. It is the TSE that is certified, not Autaxo.
  • Entries: On a cash register with a TSE, entries are signed as they are made. You post there with today’s date, and backdating is not possible. The receipt shows the TSE data and a QR code. If the TSE fails, the entry is still made, and the receipt shows the failure.
  • Reversal instead of changes: A cash register entry in Autaxo cannot be changed or deleted, only reversed. The entry and its reversal both remain in the cash book, numbered without gaps.
  • Scope: The cash register records cash only. From DMS One, the cash register entries go to your tax advisor with the DATEV and tax export.
  • Not yet included: Daily closing and exports of the cash register data are still to come in the app. This does not affect the DATEV and tax export.
  • Notification: At Autaxo, setup also includes notifying the tax office of your cash register, which our team takes care of. According to the BMF FAQ, the business remains responsible for timely notification (notification obligation topic, question 13).
  • Existing cash registers: What applies to cash registers from before the changeover is explained below in the frequently asked questions.

We are aware that the module means additional costs for many businesses. All terms are listed under Pricing for cash register & TSE. You can find more about the module on the page Cash book with TSE.

Is an Open Cash Drawer Without a TSE Permitted at a Car Dealership?

Yes, under current law (as of November 2026). There is no general obligation to use an electronic cash register.

Anyone who does not use an electronic recording system may keep an open cash drawer (BT-Drs. 18/9535, p. 2, AEAO on section 146 no. 3.1). The tax authorities understand this to mean a summary determination of daily takings, calculated backwards, and manual individual records without technical aids (AEAO on section 146 no. 2.1.4). The law does not prescribe handwriting. There is no obligation to issue receipts with an open cash drawer; it applies only to electronic recording systems (section 146a(2) sentence 1 AO, BMF FAQ, general question 3). At a car dealership, however, this approach takes considerable effort:

  • Record individually: Cash transactions must be recorded daily and, as a rule, individually (section 146(1) AO). According to the application decree, the relief for cash sales to a large number of unknown persons requires that the identity of the buyers generally plays no role in the transaction (AEAO on section 146 no. 2.2.5). When a vehicle is sold, the buyer is named in the contract and on the invoice. In our assessment, the relief will generally not help there.
  • Form: According to the application decree, the individual records can be kept in a cash book that records all cash business transactions completely and in detail. Under the decree, an orderly collection of all cash receipts, numbered for example, together with a cash report is also sufficient (AEAO on section 146 no. 3.2).
  • Count daily: The cash balance must actually be counted on every business day and recorded in a cash report from which the daily takings are calculated backwards (Federal Fiscal Court, X B 41/16). If the daily counts cannot be evidenced, this is a formal defect according to a March 2026 judgment of the Federal Fiscal Court (Bundesfinanzhof, BFH), even if the daily takings are entered in handwritten lists (BFH, X R 19/23).
  • Inspection: An open cash drawer is also subject to the cash register inspection (Kassen-Nachschau), an unannounced inspection of cash recordkeeping during normal business hours (section 146b AO, BT-Drs. 18/9535, p. 22).

There is also a limit: according to the application decree, anyone who uses an electronic recording system must, as a rule, record all revenue through it. The tax authorities raise no objection to an open cash drawer alongside it only in a spatially or organizationally clearly separable area. The condition is that the transactions there cannot be recorded via the existing system for technical reasons or because doing so would not be reasonable (AEAO on section 146 no. 2.2.3). Clarify with your tax advisor whether this approach is viable for your business.

Is a Cash Book in Excel or in an Accounting Program Allowed Without a TSE?

These are two different questions. An accounting program is exempt from the TSE requirement, but an electronic cash book is not automatically exempt. According to several tax courts and in the view of the tax authorities, a freely editable spreadsheet used as a cash book does not even satisfy the principle of immutability.

Accounting program: Section 1(1) sentence 2 no. 3 KassenSichV expressly excludes electronic accounting programs. According to the application decree, the primary record, that is, the first record of the cash transactions, is made elsewhere, for example in the cash book: only the cash income and cash expenses previously recorded in a cash register system, cash book or cash report are transferred to the accounting program (AEAO on section 146a no. 1.5.3).

Excel: Tax courts have ruled several times that a cash book in a freely editable spreadsheet such as Excel is not properly kept, because entries can be changed without the change remaining visible (for example Münster Tax Court, 4 K 541/16). The tax authorities take the same view (Frankfurt am Main Regional Finance Directorate (OFD), circular of 2020, Lower Saxony State Office for Taxes, cash recordkeeping leaflet). The standard is section 146(4) AO: the original content of an entry or record must remain ascertainable. Not every Excel file is a problem: the Münster Tax Court in 2021 held that a spreadsheet for an additional daily cash count alongside unalterable original receipts was unobjectionable.

Since When Has the TSE Requirement Applied, and How Did It Come About?

Section 146a AO has applied since January 1, 2020. This covers the TSE requirement, the issuing of receipts and the prohibition for vendors (Article 97 section 30(1) EGAO).

The background is manipulation of cash register data. In 2013, the OECD described two tools that can be used to delete or alter recorded sales after the fact: Phantomware, meaning manipulation functions hidden in the cash register software, and Zappers, external programs, for example on a USB stick (OECD report, pp. 13 to 15). In 2016, the German legislature expressly did not want an obligation to use an electronic cash register at all (BT-Drs. 18/9535, p. 2).

DateEventSource
November 26, 2010The German Federal Ministry of Finance requires individual data from electronic cash registers to be retained unalterably and in fullBMF letter
December 22, 2016Cash Register Act (Act on Protection against Manipulation of Digital Primary Records), in force since December 29, 2016: sections 146a and 146b are added to the Fiscal CodeEvaluation report, p. 6
September 26, 2017Cash Register Anti-Tampering Ordinance, in force since October 7, 2017KassenSichV
January 1, 2018Cash register inspection applicableArticle 97 section 30(2) EGAO
January 1, 2020Section 146a AO applicable: TSE requirement, obligation to issue receipts, prohibition for vendors, finesArticle 97 section 30(1) EGAO
December 31, 2022End of the transitional rule for certain electronic cash registers (Registrierkassen) that could not be upgraded with a TSE due to their designArticle 97 section 30(3) EGAO
January 1, 2025The tax office can be notified of cash register systems electronically, for example via Mein ELSTERBMF letter of June 28, 2024
July 10, 2027From this day, the EU limit of €10,000 for cash payments applies (regulation in force since July 9, 2024)Articles 80 and 90 of Regulation (EU) 2024/1624
January 1, 2028Planned, so far only a draft: cash register obligation for businesses that exceed the revenue thresholds in calendar year 2026BT-Drs. 21/8867
July 1, 2028Planned, so far only a draft: cash register obligation if the revenue thresholds are exceeded for the first time in calendar year 2027BT-Drs. 21/8867

Tax offices do actually check whether businesses comply with the TSE requirement. According to the evaluation report of the German Federal Ministry of Finance, there were 15,366 cash register inspections in 2023 and 19,080 in 2024. In around 12 percent of cases (2023) and around 10.5 percent of cases (2024), the inspectors found that the obligation to use a TSE had been breached (evaluation report, pp. 38 and 39).

What Are the Consequences of Breaching the TSE Requirement?

There is no automatic consequence. Fines and estimates each depend on specific conditions.

  • Fine: Anyone who, intentionally or recklessly, does not use an electronic recording system correctly or does not protect it with a certified TSE, and thereby makes it possible for taxes to be understated, commits an administrative offense. The fine can be up to €25,000 (section 379(1) sentence 1 nos. 4 and 5, (6) AO).
  • Receipt and notification: Under current law, breaches of the obligation to issue receipts and of the notification obligation are not subject to a fine. According to the evaluation report, however, they can be regarded as an indication that the system is not being used or protected correctly (evaluation report, p. 14). According to the application decree, the tax authority can enforce both obligations by coercive measures, for example a coercive payment (Zwangsgeld) (AEAO on section 146a no. 1.19.2).
  • Estimation: If cash recordkeeping does not comply with the recordkeeping rules and there is therefore reason to question its substantive accuracy, it loses its evidential value (section 158 AO). To the extent that the tax office cannot then determine or calculate the tax bases, it must estimate them (section 162 AO). Formal defects justify this only insofar as they give reason to doubt the substantive accuracy of the result (BFH, X R 19/21).
  • Weight: The Federal Fiscal Court requires defects to be weighed according to their significance in the individual case. A full estimate requires serious defects (BFH, X R 3/22).
  • GmbH: If the tax office adds estimated income for a GmbH, this can additionally result in a hidden profit distribution (verdeckte Gewinnausschüttung) to the shareholder. This does not necessarily follow: the undeclared income must have flowed to the shareholders, and as a rule the tax office has to prove this. If, however, it cannot be established where unrecorded income went, according to the Federal Fiscal Court this is to the shareholders’ detriment (BFH, VIII R 38/14).

According to the BMF FAQ, the tax consequences as a rule fall on the business. Whether the person acting must also expect a fine depends, according to the FAQ, on the individual case, for example on intent or recklessness (prohibition topic, question 3).

What Changes in 2027, and What Is Planned for 2028?

The EU limit on cash payments from July 10, 2027 is settled. So far, only a draft bill provides for a cash register obligation from 2028.

July 10, 2027: From then on, anyone trading in goods or providing services may only accept or make cash payments of up to €10,000 throughout the EU, even if payment is made in several linked operations (Article 80(1) and Article 90 of Regulation (EU) 2024/1624). Exactly €10,000 remains permitted. For your dealership, this means: from July 10, 2027, you may neither accept more than €10,000 in cash, for example when selling a vehicle or for a workshop invoice, nor pay such an amount in cash yourself, for example when buying a vehicle. Read more in our article on the German Anti-Money Laundering Act in the car trade.

2028, so far only a draft: Under the government draft of the Second Cash Register Act (Zweites Kassengesetz; cabinet decision of September 23, 2026), businesses whose total revenue exceeds €100,000 in a calendar year would have to use an electronic cash register system with a certified TSE from 2028. According to the wording, businesses that accept cash payments and whose cash revenue is less than €12,000 per calendar year would be exempt (BT-Drs. 21/8867). Three points would be important:

  • According to the explanatory memorandum to the draft, the open cash drawer would no longer be available to businesses subject to the cash register obligation (BT-Drs. 21/8867, p. 21).
  • Not accepting cash would not be a safe way out, because according to its wording the planned exemption would only apply to businesses that accept cash. The committees of the Federal Council (Bundesrat) recommend correcting this (Bundesrat printed paper (Bundesratsdrucksache, BR-Drs.) 585/1/26).
  • The prohibition for vendors would remain. The draft provides for moving it to a new section 146c(1) AO (BT-Drs. 21/8867, p. 9).

None of this has been adopted. The Bundestag debated the draft at first reading on November 6, 2026 (Bundestag, text archive). The Finance Committee of the Bundesrat recommends lowering the revenue threshold from €100,000 to €25,000 (BR-Drs. 585/1/26). The Bundesrat’s opinion was scheduled for November 20, 2026 and was still pending at the editorial deadline on November 18, 2026. Thresholds and dates may therefore still change. The details are in the article Second Cash Register Act in the Car Trade (German).

Frequently Asked Questions About a Cash Book Without a TSE

Do I Need a TSE for a Cash Book Kept by Hand?

Not for the cash book kept by hand itself, because the TSE requirement under section 146a AO applies to electronic recording systems. Under current law, anyone who does not use such a system may keep an open cash drawer (BT-Drs. 18/9535, p. 2, AEAO on section 146 no. 3.1) and must then record cash transactions daily and, as a rule, individually (section 146(1) AO). According to the application decree, the tax authorities raise no objection to an open cash drawer alongside an electronic recording system only for a spatially or organizationally clearly separable area in which recording via the system is not possible for technical reasons or because it would not be reasonable (AEAO on section 146 no. 2.2.3). Clarify with your tax advisor whether this approach is viable for your business.

Why Do Some Cash Book Programs Not Need a TSE?

Because the tax authorities look at the scope of functions, not at the name: if a program records only daily and closing figures, then, by reverse inference from the BMF FAQ, it does not fall under section 146a AO. Electronic accounting programs are expressly exempt (section 1(1) sentence 2 no. 3 KassenSichV). However, this exemption does not automatically apply to an electronic cash book: the application decree names the cash book as a place of primary recording (AEAO on section 146a no. 1.5.3). Whether a particular program falls under section 146a AO depends on its functions.

Must the Tax Office Be Notified of a Cash Register with a TSE?

Yes. The tax office must be notified electronically of electronic recording systems within the meaning of section 146a AO within one month of their acquisition or decommissioning (section 146a(4) AO). The notification must be made by the business that uses the cash register: according to the BMF FAQ, it can be represented but remains responsible for timely notification (BMF FAQ, notification obligation topic, question 13).

Do I Have to Issue a Receipt for Every Cash Payment?

Yes, if you record the payment with an electronic recording system within the meaning of section 146a AO and a customer or another third party is involved. You must issue the receipt and make it available in immediate temporal connection with the transaction (section 146a(2) sentence 1 AO), on paper or, with the recipient’s consent, electronically in a standardized data format (section 6 sentence 5 KassenSichV). According to the application decree, the customer does not have to take it (AEAO on section 146a no. 2.5.8). At a car dealership, you should not count on an exemption: the law provides for one only for sales to a large number of unknown persons (section 146a(2) sentence 2 AO).

What Happens to My Existing Cash Register in Autaxo?

Cash registers that you were already using before the changeover will accept entries until December 31, 2026. That is our changeover date, not a statutory deadline. From January 1, 2027, they will no longer accept entries, with two exceptions: a cash difference and the closing entry when archiving. An existing cash register does not get a TSE retroactively. A new cash register with a TSE replaces it: you order the new cash register with an opening balance of €0.00, count the cash in the previous cash register, post any discrepancy there as a cash difference and, when archiving the previous cash register, transfer the balance to the new one. You can also switch before January 1, 2027: the offer for businesses that already had a cash register in Autaxo before the changeover applies to every cash register ordered by December 31, 2026. Entries, receipts and DATEV data of the previous cash register are retained. Clarify with your tax advisor what this means for your business.

How Much Does the Cash Register with a TSE Cost in Autaxo?

The “Cash register & TSE” module costs €25 per cash register per month plus a one-time setup fee of €39 per cash register, both excluding VAT. It can be canceled monthly and added to any plan, including DMS Free. You can issue invoices in Autaxo from DMS One; in DMS Free, you post cash payments on invoices only to imported invoices. DMS Business includes one cash register. If you already had a cash register in Autaxo before the changeover, an offer applies automatically to every cash register you order by December 31, 2026: the setup fee is waived, and the cash register costs €20 instead of €25 per month, excluding VAT, for 12 months. Details are on the pricing page.

Will There Be a General Cash Register Obligation in 2028?

A cash register obligation is planned but has not been adopted. Under the government draft, businesses whose total revenue exceeds €100,000 in a calendar year would have to use an electronic cash register system with a certified TSE from 2028 (BT-Drs. 21/8867). Even under the draft, this would not be an obligation for all businesses, and thresholds and dates may still change. Read more in the article on the Second Cash Register Act (German).

Sources and Editorial Context

Legal status: November 18, 2026. Autaxo provides software for the vehicle trade and itself offers a cash book with TSE. The sections and questions about Autaxo describe our product as of November 2026. This article is for general information and does not replace tax or legal advice. You can send us notes on changed regulations or factual corrections via our contact page.

Publisher

Autaxo GmbH

Autaxo publishes this blog and provides software for vehicle dealers.